Welcome

I AM A ...

I accept the Privacy Statement and I agree to comply with it View OUR Privacy Statement.

This website uses cookies to better understand user behavior and provide the best experience. By continuing to use this website, you are consenting to the placement and retrieval of cookies on your computer by this website. Cookies will be stored for 90 days.

Never show this.

High Quality Stock Performance Held Back by Limited Earnings Visibility

June 2020
Allen T. Bond, CFA®
Allen T. Bond, CFA®
Managing Director,
Portfolio Manager

Little did we know 2020 would punch the ticket for an unexpected roller-coaster ride. After six weeks of relative tranquility, investors endured a record-setting descent into bear market territory, culminating in a 34% market decline from February 19th to March 23rd, followed by a whiplash-inducing rebound in the subsequent two months. Rather than suffering from nausea, however, many market participants now appear euphoric as equity markets march ever closer to regaining their early-2020 peaks.

While perhaps a welcome respite from the panic-stricken early stage reaction to the abrupt realization of COVID-19 related economic implications, recent elation appears inconsistent with nagging concerns associated with pandemic mitigation efforts. These worries include the long-term repercussions of social distancing measures as well as the efficacy of the healthcare response. From an investment perspective, such misgivings coalesce into uncertainty about the trajectory and magnitude of the expected earnings decline and subsequent rebound.

For quality investors, such as ourselves, additional questions surround the recent underperformance of high-quality stocks,1 as shown in Table 1.

Table 1

Source: S&P Quality Rankings

Not all market behavior in this period is perplexing. Low quality outperformance in the ‘trough-to-present’ period is consistent with the rapid change in market sentiment that typically favors traditional value stocks. However, the lack of high-quality superiority during the ‘peak-to-trough’ period is puzzling. Definitionally, high-quality businesses demonstrate relatively consistent earnings and dividends. It stands to reason that investors would gravitate towards such stocks during a period in which 70% of S&P 500 Index companies have reduced or withdrawn earnings guidance.2

Explore the Jensen Quality Strategies

  • Miscellaneous 79 final US Large Cap Growth / Large Cap Core
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Bottom Up / Fundamental
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Portfolio Companies from Jensen Quality Universe TM
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Global Large Cap Growth / Large Cap Core
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Bottom Up / Fundamental
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Portfolio Companies from Jensen Quality Universe TM
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Mid Cap Core / Mid Cap Value
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Bottom Up / Fundamental
  • Miscellaneous 79 final Portfolio Companies from Jensen Quality Universe TM

Instead, we are witnessing just the opposite. This conundrum appears linked in part to a lack of earnings visibility. Earnings stability is a key differentiator for high quality businesses. However, thus far, high quality companies have not fared much better than the overall market in terms of maintaining financial outlooks. In The Jensen Quality Growth Fund, (70% of which is invested in stocks rated A- or better) nearly 60% of the companies have withdrawn or reduced earnings predictions since the start of the year.

A lack of reliable earnings and earnings forecasts causes investors to speculate. In recent months, such conjecture has taken the form of optimism over fiscal and monetary stimulus and a continuation of momentum trading, with little apparent concern for underlying business prospects.

These trends suggest that market participants are willing to overlook expectations of both a precipitous decline in 2020 earnings (-30%) and a rosy 2021 recovery scenario (+48%).3

Perhaps our metaphorical rollercoaster ride is nearly over. Or, maybe we are in store for a few more high-speed twists and turns. Regardless, looking forward, we foresee an improved environment for high quality stocks. Earnings visibility should naturally improve as the economy adjusts to post-pandemic norms, thereby illuminating differentiated, more sustainable business models and setting a more meaningful baseline for future expectations. We are optimistic that tangible—as opposed to speculative—financial results will remind investors to refocus their attention on long-term business fundamentals and the importance of knowing what they own.

1 Source: S&P Quality Rankings. S&P ranks index constituents from A+ though C based on trailing earnings and dividend consistency. We consider stocks rated A- and above as high quality and those rated B+ and below as low quality.

2 Source: https://www.gartner.com/en/news-room/press-releases/2020-05-15-gartner-analysis-of-s-and-p-500-company-earnings-shows-70-percent-have-revised-or-withdrawn-guidance-due-to-covid-19-disruption

3 Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices: 6/3/20 despite both assumptions resting upon an arguably flimsier-than-normal foundation due to limited corporate forecasts and a plethora of risks that could easily upset a fragile economy.

Mutual fund investing involves risk, and principal loss is possible. The Jensen Quality Growth Fund is non-diversified, meaning it may concentrate its assets in fewer individual holdings than a diversified fund. The prices of growth stocks may be sensitive to changes in current or expected earnings, may experience larger price swings and may be out of favor with investors at different periods of time.

The S&P 500 Index is a market value weighted index consisting of 500 stocks chosen for market size, liquidity and industry group representation. The Index is unmanaged, and one cannot invest directly in the Index. Index performance is not indicative of fund performance.

For more complete information about The Jensen Quality Growth Fund including investment objectives, risks, fees and expenses, please click here for a current prospectus. Read the prospectus or summary prospectus carefully before you invest or send money.

To obtain updated performance information that is current as of the most recent month- and quarter-end, please call 1.800.992.4144 or visit jenseninvestment.com.

The Jensen Funds are distributed by Quasar Distributors, LLC.